Infrastructure, Climate Change and the Economy: Part 3 - Measuring GDP vs GPI
| 02.11.2011 | 08:17:1524110 |
February 11, 2011: Early last year, Maryland Governor Martin O'Malley announced new plans for a state-run program which helps policy makers and citizens accurately measure Maryland's standard of living. The Genuine Progress Indicator, an online tool, uses the health of the environment and society as indicators with traditional economic calculations to find an overall grade. "Just as the elements of our natural world must be balanced to ensure a healthy ecosystem," O'Mally said, "so too must be the elements of how we judge our success as a State. A strong economy, a clean environment and a healthy citizenry go hand in hand; none can be a true measure of success without supporting the other two."
The idea is not new. In a 1968 speech given at the University of Kansas, Robert Kennedy outlined the ways in which using GDP as the sole indicator of success had its shortcomings. "The gross national product," Kennedy said, "measures everything ... except that which makes life worthwhile."
And back in 2009, the New York Times reported about a European Union project aimed at taking steps to monitor environmental stress
. Similarly, and more recently, India announced its own plans to take into consideration the environment when measuring its GDP
Basically, proponents say, looking at the amount of cars manufactured, or the amount of paper made from cutting trees down, or the production of pharmaceuticals for hospitals, does not take into account the environmental stress those activities cause. Deforestation, or the health of the water, or the purity of the air affect populations, agriculture and infrastructure and that stresses to the environment are costs then pushed onto societies who have to pay for them, thus reducing actual economic growth. Additionally, mismanagement of environmental resources leads to increased stresses, a lack of resources, and health concerns
"If we are reporting GDP growth of 8 percent a year," Indian Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh said during a conference in New Delhi, "actual GDP growth that takes into account environmental costs may be 2.5 percentage points lower."
At the Gund Institute for Ecological Economics at the University of Vermont
, several GPI measures have been released. Focusing on Northeast Ohio, Baltimore, Northern Vermont and Vermont, Chittenden County and Burlington, the GPI measurements were taken to represent roughly 50 years of growth.
In Ohio for instance, out of the 17 counties measured, per capita GPI "was greatest in suburban counties and lowest in urban areas. These trends are largely driven by gains in personal consumption relative to rising environmental, social and economic costs. Important costs include those of income inequality, climate change, nonrenewable resource depletion, and consumer durables." While in Baltimore, a generally positive GPI growth. However some variables "such as the cost of crime, the cost of underemployment, and the loss of leisure time" added to mixed results due to environmental health.
Currently, aside from Vermont, Minnesota
have GPI reports.
"The GPI will help ensure that our economic growth will not come at the cost of our natural resources, and that they both support our progress toward a sustainable future and a better quality of life for all Maryland families," O'Malley said.
Copyright ©2006 NCORP, Inc.
NCORP and the Kennedy School of Government Collaborate on the National Blueprint for Secure Communities
Working in partnership with the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, the ReadyCommunities Partnership is reaching out to first responders, local officials, the private sector and citizens throughout the nation to develop the National Blueprint for Secure Communities. The Blueprint will be the focus of the first National Congress for Secure Communities in November and serve as a roadmap for any community striving for resiliency during the first hours of a national or large-scale crisis. Click Here to read more...
National Press Club Briefing on National Blueprint June 20th
In partnership with the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University and it's non-profit, government and corporate partners, NCORP is reaching out to first responders, local officials, the private sector and citizens throughout the nation to develop a National Blueprint for Secure Communities. The Blueprint is a project under the ReadyAmerica Initiative, and was the focus of the National Press Club briefing at 11:30 a.m. on June 20, 2006. The Blueprint will serve as a roadmap for any community working to reach a level of excellence in their preparedness.
Preliminary Report from Midwest Summit
The Midwest Summit Police Chiefs Association met May 3rd and 4th in LaCrosse, Wisconsin to develop public/private partnerships that augment and multiply community preparedness, response and recovery capabilities. NCORP joined the Summit to incorporate the output of the May 3rd Summit sessions into the National Blueprint for Secure Communities. Click Here to download the draft draft preliminary report of the Summit.
More Press Items:
Homeland Security Journal coverage
Speech at the Harvard Forum
The First 72 Hours Meeting Agenda
ReadyAmerica: The First 72 Hours
Photographs of the November 16th Meeting
Draft Transcript of Preparedness Congress
December 17-18, 2007...
National Congress for Secure Communities at the Capitol Hill Hyatt, Washington, D.C.
May 31, 2007...
Initial meeting in Hamilton County, IN with county/city stakeholders on the 5-community pilot project.
May 7, 2007 ...
Planning meeting in Charleston, SC with community stakeholders on the 5-community pilot.
April 25, 2007...
Meeting in Pontiac, Oakland County, Michigan for the 5-community Pilot.
January 18, 2007...
Southwestern Regional Meeting of the NCORP Advisory Committee in Galveston, Texas
August 10, 2006...
Code Red for international flights to the U.S. originating in the UK: Code Orange for commerical U.S. domestic flights; Code Yellow for the U.S.
July 7, 2005...
Code Orange for metropolitan transportation and rail systems
January 18, 2005...
Code Yellow is in effect
Why Your Membership in ReadyCorps Will Help Strengthen Homeland Security
September 11, 2001 has not only changed the way communities view their preparation and response to crisis, but also redefined the role that citizens and corporations have in helping their communities prepare for and respond to threat and crisis. Though local, state and federal governments are responsible at one level or another, there just are not enough resources to protect all communities and property at all times, nor to respond equally or quickly. The threat and the country are too open and large.
The National Council on Readiness and Preparedness has formed ReadyCorps to bring corporations together with communities, responders and governments to increase community surge capacity during incidents of mass casualty or destruction. ReadyCorps members will establish a corporate Crisis Response Officer (CRO) for each corporate facility, to serve as a contact point between responders and corporations to share information and assets, create preparedness response strategies and generally develop simple but effective ways to train and prepare employees for threat or crisis as resources to the responder sector during community response.
Click here to read more...